Find an Ohio auto insurance agent or broker and shop multiple companies and save money. Although our secure website provides the lowest rates from the top-rated companies, as a courtesy, we also provide a comprehensive listing of car insurance agencies and brokers here in the Buckeye state. The list is updated monthly.
You can choose either to provide your zip code at the top of the page or find a representative in your area. Regardless of which method you view prices, you’ll be glad to know that prices in Ohio are among the lowest in the US. Savings is typically 10%-40%.
Columbus Area Auto Insurance Brokers
ABA Agency 2760 S. Hamilton Rd. Columbus 43232 (614) 864-5911
Sylvia Antoinette 1 Nationwide Plaza #3 Columbus 43215 (614) 249-2141
Affordable Agency 1180 W. Broad St. Columbus 43222 (614) 457-7000
AllAmerican Casualty 1654 Brice Rd. Reynoldsburg 43068 (614) 864-5678
Apollo Agency 3677 Karl Rd. Suite C Columbus 43224 (614) 261-7653
Ballou Agency 2810 Cleveland Ave. Columbus 43224 (614) 267-9217
Beim And Grundstein Agency 2770 E. Main St. Suite 1 Columbus 43209 (614) 231-3696
Baum And Associates Agency 170 S. Yearling Rd. Columbus 43213 (614) 237-7683
Bennett Agency 700 S. High St. Columbus 43206 (614) 443-4226
Chip Berry Agency 8041 Hosbrook Rd. Suite 414 Cincinnati 45236 (513) 444-2100
Botkin Services 4218 Indianola Ave. Columbus 43214 (614) 265-9999
Bowers Agency 1792 Sawgrass Dr. Reynoldsburg 43068 (614) 866-7269
Bradley Group 5150 E. Main St. Columbus 43213 (614) 863-9300
Ted Briggs 2545 Pretzinger Rd. Suite L. Columbus 43209 (614) 235-6667
Brubaker Agencies 2700 E. Main St. Suite 104 Columbus 43209 (614) 239-1776
Buckeye Benefit Counseling 1857 Northwest Blvd. Suite 203 Columbus 43212 (614) 655-5635
Buren Group 585 S. Front St. Suite 200 Columbus (614) 942-1226
Burrey Agency 4277 Donlyn Ct. Columbus 43232 (614) 501-9480
Theresa Bush 2284 E. Main St. Bexley 43209 (614) 884-2314
Thomas A. Byrd 5212 W. Broad St. Suite L. Columbus 43228 (614) 870-5141
Call Agency 21 W. Broad St. Fl#2 Columbus 43215 (614) 468-0334
Cambridge Group 853 S. High St. Columbus 43206 (614) 586-1053
Collins Agency 4449 Easton Way Fl 2 Columbus 43219 (614) 231-1988
Gianna R. Cone 1495 Morse Rd. Suite 307 Columbus 43229 (614) 267-7865
Dan Coonfare Agency 1080 Fishinger Rd. Columbus 43221 (614) 486-5400
Cooper Group 1991 Guilford Rd. Columbus 43221 (614) 488-2667
Glen Crowell 3585 Refugee Drive. Columbus 43214 (614) 235-0777
Tom Crumrine Jr. 583 S. Yearling Rd. Columbus 43213 (614) 575-2643
Danduran & Associates 1827 Obrien Rd. Columbus 43228 (614) 777-8200
Trevis A. Davie 5310 E. Main St. Suite 204 Columbus 43213 (614) 367-
Davis Agency 29 Federick St. Columbus 43206 (614) 443-0533
Marc Davis 3000 E, Main St. #238 B Bexley 43209 (614) 353-3710
Dehan Enterprises 762 E. Main St. Columbus 43205 (614) 238-3520
Defusco & Associates 538 E. Town St. Columbus 43215 (614) 221-8285
Dennis And Nelson 130 E. Chestnut St. Suite 200 Columbus 43215 (614) 222-0911
Kimberly Derwent 4018 Alum Creek Drive Columbus 43207 (614) 409-9196
Patricia A. Dews 114 Norton Rd. Columbus 43228 (614) 878-9720
Lisa S. Diemer 3040 Riverside Dr. Suite 209 Columbus 43221 (614) 488-9445
Dressel And Evans Agency 1527 Northwest Blvd. Columbus 43212 (614) 488-9723
Jerry Doherty 21 W. Broad St. Suite 200 Columbus 43215 (614) 461-7833
Dulin Agency 2011 Riverside Dr. Suite 110 Columbus 43221 (614) 486-0761
Renee Dutton 2471 Westmont Blvd. Upper Arlington 43221 (614) 485-9077
Enterprise Agency 4345 Donlyn Ct. C Columbus 43232 (614) 501-9480
Ernie F. Epitropoulos 4701 Olentangy River Rd. Suite 102 Columbus 43214 (614) 451-2030
Bob Erlanger 3821 N. High St. Columbus 43214 (614) 451-6600
Ezcarinsurance 3783 S. High St. Columbus 43207 (614) 497-9500
Adam Ford Agency 3043 W. Broad St. Columbus 43204 (614) 276-3591
Gardiner Allen Deroberts 777 W. Goodale Blvd. Suite 200 Columbus 43212 (614) 857-6428
Goree Agency 64 Parsons Ave. Columbus 43215 (614) 260-9680
David Grant 4612 N. High St. Columbus 43214 (614) 262-1055
Green Light Agency 5310 E. Main Suite 201 Columbus 43213 (614) 575-2643
Grubers Columbus Agency 3040 Riverside Drive Suite 104 Columbus 43221 614) 486-0611
James H. Harley 4709 Trabue Woods Ct. Columbus 43228 (614) 495-6783
Henderson Agency 3620 N. High St. Suite 105 Columbus 43204 (614) 884-0970
Danny Hilton 3276 Mores Rd. Suite B Columbus 43231 (614) 475-8808
Huntington Agency 7 Easton Oval Columbus 43219 (800) 628-7064
Raymond G. Inglis 3620 N.High St. Suite B8 Columbus 43214 (614) 882-4024
Integrated Financial Systems – 4207 E. Broad St. Suite F Columbus 43213 (614) 238-5000
Intermediaries 280 N. High St. Suite 300 Columbus 43215 (614) 444-1744
Isner Associates 221 S. Hamilton Rd. Columbus 43232 (614) 236-8691
Vic Jimenez 35 N. Wilson Rd. Columbus 43204 (614) 272-5456
Robert Jackson 2690 E. Main St. Bexley 43209 (614) 235-5413
Adam Kaufman 3363 Tremont Rd. Suite 103 Columbus Oh 43204 (614) 457-6252
Amie Kim 1246 N. High St. Columbus 43206 (614) 586-8701
Jamie Koutras 3363 Tremont Rd. Suite 203 Columbus Oh 43221 (614) 442-1490
Ledbetter Group 1767 Harrisburg Pike Columbus 43223 (614) 351-1134
Eric Ley Agency 2788 Northwest Blvd. Columbus 43221 (614) 488-2065
Lithira Agency 700 Morse Rd. Suite 218 Columbus 43214 (614) 847-1600
Neace Lukens 285 Cozzins St. Columbus 43215 (614) 224-0772
Mabukar Company 3283 Cleveland Ave. Suite 11 Columbus Oh 43224 (614) 632 3171
Mackinnon Insurance 921 Chatham Ln. Suite 300 Columbus 43221 (614) 224-5944
Maloof Agency 2362 N. High St. Columbus 43206 (614) 263-6301
MAPFRE Agency 3590 Twin Creeks Drive Columbus 43204 (800) 222-2114
Marco Miller 1086 S. High St. Columbus 43206 (614) 445-6880
The Matson Agency 1275 Demorest Rd. Columbus 43204 (614) 274-1444
Jackie Meadows 2036 8 Mile Rd. Cincinnati 45244 (513) 474-4940
Merry Agency 2554 Morse Rd. Columbus 43231 (614) 261-3690
Murray & Sons Agency 301 S. Hamilton Rd. Columbus 43213 (614) 237-0291
Steve Nelson 4495 E. Broad Street Columbus 43213 (614) 866-5511
Newco Agency 2939 Kenny Rd. Columbus 43221 (614) 448-8404
Nikki Ogunduyile 20 S, Third St. Suite 310 Columbus 43215 (614) 274-7130
Olde Town Agency 1157 Oak St. Columbus 43205 (614) 288-8885
Oswald Companies 349 W. Nationwide Blvd. Columbus 43215 (614) 744-4242
Palmer Miller Nelson Agency 3215 N. High St. Columbus 43202 (614) 261-6300
Penn Summit Agency 500 S, 4th St. Columbus (614) 228-4496
Lonny Perlman 3314 Morse Rd. Suite 208 Columbus 43213 (614) 337-1300
Pfeifer-Orenstein Agency 3291 E. Main St. Columbus 43202 (614) 235-7050
Phillips Agency 938 Dennison Ave. Columbus 43201 (614) 294-4421
Pri-Value Agency 1496 Morse Rd. Columbus 43229 (614) 388-9989
Russell A. Popp 2844 Johnstown Rd. Columbus 43219 (614) 471 5557
Loretta Powell 3040 Riverside Drive Suite 220 Columbus 43221 614) 481-0911
Felix Quachey 1100 Mores Rd. Suite 301 Columbus 43229 (614) 536-0237
Quick Auto Agency 2210 Morse Centre Rd. Columbus 43229 (614) 470-9801
QuickInsured 580 N. 4th St. Suite 500 Columbus 43215 (800) 831-1670
Reed Agency 2770 E. Main St. Suite 1 Columbus 43209 (614) 236-1787
Rensch Agency 2969 Daisy Lane Columbus 43204 (614) 272-7169
Tim Reis Agency 931 N. High St. Columbus 43201 (614) 444-7881
Norm Risoya 806 Bethel Rd. Columbus 43214 (614) 326-1406
Matthew Rudolph 3719 S. High St. Columbus 43207 (614) 702-2020
Bob Rutter 935 Timberman Rd. Columbus 43212 (740) 243-8309
Mark Schaefer 1258 Grandview Ave. Suite C Grandview Heights 43212 (614) 486-3276
JR Scott Agency 3620 N. High St. Suite 203 Columbus 43214 (614) 263-9699
Sergakis Agency 4942 Reed Rd. Columbus 43220 (614) 451-2232
David K. Sichko 1885 W. 5th Ave. Columbus 43212 (614) 481-8869
Matt Simonds Agency 2986 N. High St. Columbus 43202 (614) 262-6700
Mark Smith 3821 N. High Sr. Columbus 43214 (614) 451-6600
Eric Snider 4911 W. Broad St. Columbus 43228 (614) 851-1300
Gary Snowden 1369 Georgesville Rd. Columbus 43228 (614) 272-2300
Snyder Agency 1387 Chambers Rd. Columbus 43212 (614) 486-7646
John Snyder 3440 S. hamilton Rd. Columbus 43232 (614) 864-3882
Sokol Agency 2691 E. Main St. Suite 104 Columbus 43209 (614) 235-111
Soller Agency 891 S. James Rd. Columbus 43277 (614) 235-2815
David Stanley & Associates 699 Harrisburg Pike Suite A Columbus 43223 (614) 274-7775
Sterling Group 4218 Indianola Ave. Columbus 43214 (614) 425-1944
Thomas-Fenner-Woods Agency 1500 Lake Shore Dr. Suite 400 Columbus 43204 (614) 481-4300
Demirel Tolga 1108 N. High St. Columbus 43201 (614) 300-3030
Town And Village Service 1580 Fishinger Rd. Columbus 43221 (614) 457-6913
Tri-Wood Agency 1000 Georgesville Rd. Columbus 43228 (614) 276-7821
Gwynn Vaughan 3079 W. Broad St. Columbus 43204 (614) 278-0278
VLP Agency 2541 Franksway Cort Columbus 43232 (614) 495-6783
Al Washington 1010 Old Henderson Rd. Suite 204 Columbus 43220 (614) 564-9156
Wells Fargo Insurance Services 580 N. 4th St. Suite 400 Columbus 43215 (614) 228- 5565
Buddy White 1500 S. Hamilton Rd. Columbus 43227 (614) 864-1050
Glenn R. Williams 2930 N. High St. Columbus 43202 (614) 268-3567
Guy Williams Agency 1387 Chambers Rd. Columbus 43212 (614) 488-1101
Kent Williamson Insurance 2401 Eastcleft Dr. Columbus 43221 (614) 451-2957
Willis Of Ohio 775 Yard St. Suite 200 Columbus 43212 (614) 457-7000
Thomas Wilson 4450 Kenny Rd. Columbus 43220 (614) 300-7779
Yelena Uchiteleva 233 S. Hamilton Rd. Columbus 43213 (614) 235-1702
Cincinnati Area Auto Insurance Brokers – Find Cheap Cincinnati Car Insurance
William Abanto 3218 Montana Ave. Cincinnati 45211 (513) 662-8500
Advantage Network 4739 Delhi Ave. Cincinnati 45238 (513) 922-9460
Assured Neace Lukens 4000 Smith Road Suite 400 Cincinnati 45209 (513) 333-0700
Berling Agency 2262 Jefferson Ave. Cincinnati 45212 (513) 502-1028
Broz Agency 3900 Harrison Ave. Cincinnati 45211 (513) 662-5112
Leah Brantley 6323 Glenway Avenue Cincinnati 45211 (513) 662-7283
Broz Agency 3900 Harrison Ave. Cincinnati 45211 (513) 662-5112
Burkhart Agency 4291 Foley Rd. Cincinnati 45238 (513) 244-2500
Chaz H. Bilz Agency 412 Madison Ave. Covington, KY. 41011 (859) 431-1235
CAI Agency 2035 Reading Rd. Cincinnati 45202 (513) 221-1140
Michael Cappel 3985 Race Rd. Suite 13 Cincinnati 45211 (513) 574-5353
CMI Agency 3960 Red Bank Rd. Suite 100 Cincinnati 45227 (513) 605-3500
Christopher Wade Chapman Agency 435 Martin Luther King Drive E. Cincinnati 45229 (513) 221-1500
CMS Agency 2756 Erie Ave. Cincinnati 45208 (513) 321-2000
Fred Copley Agency 7182 Pippin Rd. Cincinnati 45239 (513) 931-0599
Covington Insurance Agency 503 W. 6th Street Covington, Ky. 41011 (859) 652-2016
John Curry 4953 Delhi Avenue Cincinnati 45238 (513) 582-1369
Richard Curry Jr. 4953 Delhi Pike Cincinnati 45238 (513) 451-5205
Dabbelt Agency 5932 Glenway Ave. Cincinnati 45238 (513) 451-8050
Joe Dalbey 20 N. Grand Ave. Suite 9 Fort Thomas, Ky. 41075 (859) 781-5633
Stephen F. Deters Agency 2191 Victory Parkway Cincinnati 45206 (513) 861-9900
Chuck Detmering 2638 Kipling Ave. Cincinnati 45239 (513) 741-4500
W P Dolle 201 E. 5th St Suite 1000 Cincinnati 45202 (513) 421-6515
Alison Doner 3006 Portsmouth Ave. Cincinnati 45208 (513) 871-5300
Bob Donnelly 2063 Beechmont Ave. Cincinnati 45230 (513) 231-4975
Driehaus Group 700 Walnut Street Suite 208 Cincinnati 45202 (513) 977-6860
Jim Duffy Agency 4942 Bonaventure Ct. Cincinnati 45238 (513) 347-6000
Raymond F. Folz & Company 2436 Central Parkway Cincinnati 45214 (513) 621-9440
Larry Garrison 5710 Wooster Pike Suite 202 Cincinnati 45227 (513) 271-6370
Eric Geiger 6900 Miami Ave. Cincinnati 45243 (513) 574-0321
Globe Agency 2619 Erie Ave. Cincinnati 45208 (513) 871-3330
Gross Agency 26 N. Fort Thomas Ave. Fort Thomas, Ky. 41075 (859) 781-0434
Barbara J. Hall 4010 N. Bend Rd. Suite 300 Cincinnati 45211 (513) 347-9492
Hauser Agency 4009 Erie Ct. Cincinnati 45227 (513) 271-5070
Hauser Group 5905 E. Gailbraith Rd. Suite 9000 Cincinnati 45236 (513) 745-9200
Henry Agency 2757 Observatory Ave. Cincinnati 45208 (513) 871-7700
Huber Agency 5618 Glenway Ave. Cincinnati 45238 (513) 574-4676
Huesman Insurance Group 3654 Glenmore Ave. Cincinnati 45211 (513) 385-5585
Huntington Agency 105 E. 4th Street Cincinnati 45202 (513) 762-1803
Huwel Insurance Group 822 Delta Ave. Suite 3 Cincinnati 45226 (513) 321-1400
Hyde Park Insurance Partners 2702 Erie Avenue Suite 308 Cincinnati 45208 (513) 533-0228
Intelli Choice 400 York St. Newport, KY. 41071 (513) 777-3606
Kaine Insurance 5963 Glenway Avenue Cincinnati 45238 (513) 451-7799
Jerry Kautzman 3344 Westbourne Ave. Cincinnati 45248 (513) 661-2445
Stephen Linz Agency 2117 Beechmont Ave. Cincinnati 45230 (513) 231-0333
Terry Long 3962 Montgomery Rd. Cincinnati 45212 (513) 351-0917
Lori Agency 3310 Westbourne Agency Cincinnati 45248 (513) 661-2445
Daniel Losch 4465 Bridgetown Rd. Cincinnati 45211 (513) 922-5000
Frank Luttmer Agency 4920 Glenway Avenue Cincinnati 45238 (513) 921-5185
Mariemont Agency 5725 Dragon Way Suite 200 Cincinnati 45227 (513) 271-4060
RG McGraw Agency 324 E. 4th Cincinnati 45202 (513) 381-7881
Greg Meinberg 3322 Erie Ave. Suite 102 Cincinnati 45208 (513) 533-1661
Meissner Agency 3710 Harrison Ave. Cincinnati 45211 (513) 612-9857
Dianne Michael 5062 Delhi Ave. Cincinnati 45238 (513) 451-8700
A.E. Olverson Agency 1669 California Ave. Cincinnati 45237 (513) 242-5511
Oswald Companies 201 E. 5th St. Suite 1900 Cincinnati 45202 (216) 367-4915
AM Peck & Company 414 Walnut Street Cincinnati 45202 (513) 721-3915
Michael Pippin 6097 Montgomery Rd. Cincinnati 45213 (513) 531-4800
Howard Richards 5204 Beechmont Ave. Cincinnati 45230 (513) 609-4878
Jason Riegelsberger 4477 Bridgetown Rd. Cincinnati 45211 (513) 574-8811
Rigling Financial Agency 3968 Montgomery Rd. Cincinnati 45212 (513) 731-2099
RM Price Agency 2503 Fairview Ave. Cincinnati 45219 (513) 421-5700
Brad Robbins 3111 Mozart Ave. Cincinnati 45211 (513) 662-2200
Roth Associates 1953 Mears Ave. Cincinnati 45230 (513) 2321-1050
Rudd Agency 239 W. Cort Street 45202 (513) 721-7766
Robert A. Ryan Agency 2212 Victory Parkway Cincinnati 45206 (513) 221-1454
Schaefer Agency 417 Anderson Ferry Rd. Cincinnati 45238 (513) 922-7100
Mike Schweppe 5956 Glenway Ave. Cincinnati 45238 (513) 922-1442
Bob Shropshire Sons 806 Main St. Cincinnati 45202 (513) 655-2023
Noah Stelzer 6923 Miami Avenue Cincinnati 45243 (513) 272-6000
Strom Agency 6813 Bryn Mawr Dr. Cincinnati 45242 (513) 477-9522
Thompson-Boerger Agency 1514 Dixie Highway Park Hills Ky 41011 (859) 291-3914
Titan Insurance 3511 Glenmore Avenue Cincinnati 45211 (513) 825-2999
Steve Ulmer 3518 Glenmore Avenue Cincinnati 45211 (513) 662-4300
USI Services 312 Elm St. Fl 24 Cincinnati 45202 (513) 852-6300
Wagner Insurance Services 4466 Bridgetown Rd. Cincinnati 45211 (513) 574-3600
Deatria Walker 3252 North Bend Rd. Cincinnati 45239 (513) 661-0400
Wells Fargo Services 720 E. Pete Rose Way Suite 400 Cincinnati 45202 (513) 657-3116
Christopher Whitehead 1671 Park Rd. Suite 10 Fort Wight, Ky. 41011 (859) 344-8588
Wally Wong 2637 Erie Avenue Cincinnati 45208 (513) 321-6969
H. Wilson & Associates 4240 Airport Rd. Suite 111 Cincinnati 45226 (513) 325-9357
Winters Financial Network 5556 Cheviot Rd. Suite B Cincinnati Oh 45247 (513) 662-4800
Wyler Insurance Services – 8950 Colerain Ave. Cincinnati 45251 (513) 245-6888
EP Zimmer Agency 2148 Gilbert Ave. Cincinnati 45206 (513) 381-1919
Zinser Agency 5310 Glenway Ave. Cincinnati 45238 (513) 451-8898
Cleveland Area Auto Insurance Brokers
First National Agency 55 Public Square Suite 1460 Cleveland 44113 (216) 634-9752
Huntington Agency 200 Public Square Cleveland 44113 (216) 515-6636
Pinkney-Perry Agency 526 Superior Ave. E. Suite 910 Cleveland 44114 (216) 795-1995
Right Track Agency 815 Superior Ave. E. Suite 1412 Cleveland 44114 (440) 862-0352
USI Insurance Services 1301 E. 9th St. Suite 3800 Cleveland 44114 (216) 241-4344
Oswald Companies 1100 Superior Ave. Suite 1500 44114 (216) 367-8787
United Agencies Group 1422 Euclid Ave. Suite 900 Cleveland 44115 (269) 696-8044
Steven Lu Associates 2999 Payne Ave. Suite 118 Cleveland 44114 (216) 861-0182
Sam J. Saraniti 3100 W. 25th St. Cleveland 44109 (216) 281-3900
Cortez Agency 3566 W. 105th St. Suite 3 Cleveland 44111 (216) 938-9770
Zak Insurance Group 4306 Ridge Rd. Cleveland 44144 (216) 661-2533
Burcham Agency 4768 Broadview Rd. Cleveland 44109 (216) 741-2222
Halter Group 2026 Murray Hill Rd. Suite 109 Cleveland 44106 (216) 297-0499
Assured Agency 4715 State Rd. Cleveland 44109 (216) 485-5775
Rutledge Group 13124 Shaker Square Suite 300 Cleveland 44120 (216) 561-4444
Superior Auto Insurance 13217 Superior Ave. Cleveland 44122 (216) 268-4800
Agency Associates 5634 Broadway Ave. Cleveland 44127 (440) 888-3065
Rivera’s Agency 3778 Pearl Rd. Cleveland 44109 (216) 661-7923
Chalasinski Group 3807 E. 71st St. Cleveland 44105 (440) 838-5383
Cortez Agency 3566 W. 105th St. Suite 3 Cleveland 44111 (216) 938-9770
Gibbs Group 13905 Kinsman Rd. Cleveland 44120 (216) 830-2222
Leusch Agency 16903 Fischer Rd. Cleveland 44107 (216) 228-3333
CLE Group 1502 Puritas Ave. Suite B Cleveland 44135 (216) 659-1661
Tuxedo Agency 6148 Broadview Rd. Cleveland 44134 (216) 398-7888
The Alpha Group 4200 Rockside Rd. Cleveland 44131 (216) 520-3300
Tower Agencies 4500 Rockside Rd. Suite 400 Cleveland 44131 (216) 267-4466
Insurance Systems Group 4500 Rockside Rd. Suite 400 Cleveland 44131 (216) 236 7760
Omni Star Agency 3362 Henderson Rd. Cleveland 44122 (216) 205-0058
Camper Agency 6200 Rockside Rd. Suite 100 Cleveland 44131 (216) 795-5644
Haudenschild Agency 6200 Rockside Rd. Suite 100 Cleveland 44131 (216) 642-8009
Hoynes Agency 17522 Harvard Ave. Cleveland 44128 (216) 831-2770
The Morrow Group 17877 Saint Clair Ave. Cleveland 44410 (216) 738-1700
Liberty Mutual Agency 26600 Detroit Rd. Suite 280 Cleveland 44145 (440) 808-0288
Pike Agency 15327 Pine Hill Trail Cleveland 44130 (216) 441-1989
Dayton Area Auto Insurance Brokers
Code Agency 355 W. Monument Ave. Dayton 45402 (937) 228-5314
Marsh & McLennan Agency 409 E. Monument Ave. Suite 400 Dayton 45402 (937) 228-4135
McFall & Son Agency 115 Linwood Street Suite 11 Dayton 45405 (937) 461-2246
Guild And Landis Agency 105 Riverside Drive Dayton 45405 (937) 224-1521
Rogers-McNay Agency 105 Riverside Drive Dayton 45405 (937) 278-8201
Comments on this entry are closed.